Support the Whiskey Shelf

jack daniel's sinatra select review

Jack Daniel's Sinatra Select Tennessee Whiskey

June 9, 2020

Follow on Instagram
Jack Daniels Sinatra Select review

Distillery: Jack Daniel’s (Brown Forman)

Type & Region: Tennessee Whiskey, Tennessee, USA

Alcohol: 45%

Composition: 80% corn, 8% rye, 12% malted barley

Aged: NAS

Color: 1.2/2.0 on the color scale (chestnut, oloroso sherry)

Price: $100-180 (750mL or 1L)

From the Jack Daniel’s website:

“Sinatra Select pays tribute to Jack’s biggest fan: Frank Sinatra. Made with our unique “Sinatra Barrels” that have deep grooves specially carved into their staves to expose the whiskey to extra layers of toasted oak. This added exposure imparts a rich amber color, bold character, and pleasant smokiness, punctuated by an incredibly smooth vanilla finish. Much like Frank, this Tennessee Whiskey is one of a kind.”

Company Website

jack daniel's sinatra select overview

To be honest, Jack Daniel’s does a good job of describing what Sinatra Select is, so see above for the information straight from their website. All I can really add is that a few other whiskeys, such as Jefferson’s Twin Oak, have experimented with adding grooves into the barrel staves to impart additional oak character. Since I haven’t had the Twin Oak, I can’t comment on how good or bad it is. With the Sinatra Select though, I am optimistic that it will do wonders because Jack Daniel’s Old No. 7 and Gentleman Jack are just not for me. Let’s raise a glass to Frank Sinatra and learn more about his whiskey (not actually but in spirit maybe) in this Jack Daniel’s Sinatra Select review.

Brown Forman Lineup of Reviews

Cooper’s Craft

Gentleman Jack

Jack Daniel’s Old No. 7

Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel Select

Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Rye

Old Forester 1920 Prohibition

Old Forester Rye

Woodford Reserve

Woodford Batch Proof

jack daniel's sinatra select smell

Jack Daniel’s Sinatra Select emanates gentle and round caramel nougat, vanilla buttercream, dry grass, and freshly cut wood, with light hints of dark fruits and orange. As expected, the 90 proof gives off very little heat, so it’s very easy to drink. I don’t dislike this, so that’s a good start.

 

Sinatra Select wakes up a little after swirling, a welcome wake-up call. I smell a gentle waft of honey, roasted oak, dried grass, vanilla buttercream, and a little roasted brown sugar, mint, and heat. Even with the grass, it doesn’t quite turn into dried peanut shells. Buttercream picks up the most, providing a slightly funky and sour vanilla scent (but in a good way). As I sift through the scents, I discover a light cherry and citrus foundation that accompany the oak and adds another dimension of sweetness. From memory, Sinatra Select has more underlying fruit and fewer harsh roasted notes, although no particular fruit really stands out to me. It’s more blended fruit smoothie than sliced fruit bowl. All in all, it smells good, but it’s far from complex or interesting. Given its grassiness, it reminds me a lot of Evan Williams Bottled in Bond…you know the one that’s under $20. 

jack daniel's sinatra select taste & aftertaste

Jack Daniel’s Sinatra Select starts with slightly nutty caramel, vanilla, lightly toasted oak, and virtually no heat (as expected). It’s already apparent that this tastes a little richer than it smells. Of all things, the mouthfeel is actually quite round, creamy, and thick as if it were 100+ proof, but the flavors don’t quite match that level.

 

With “chewing” I taste a pleasant blend of caramel, vanilla, dried grass, oak, and orange with a little cinnamon, apple, and fresh mint. There’s an ambient fruitiness here that also includes pear and a little creamy banana, providing a little extra welcome depth. Again, the mouthfeel is surprisingly viscous that lends a roundness and softness, but the flavors are often dulled as well.

 

Citrused honey, vanilla buttercream, dried grass, peanut shells, oak tannins, and mint remain on the finish after I swallow the Sinatra Select. I can’t shake the fact that this tastes a lot like Evan Williams Bottled in Bond, a Heaven Hill bourbon. “Chewing” leaves a light alcohol tingle, caramel, vanilla, oak, and nuts that turn into banana after a few minutes. At the end of all of this, Jack Daniel’s Sinatra Select is predominately a straightforward whiskey with a few nice wrinkles that overall doesn’t pique my interest, but it also doesn’t have any rough edges to make it unpleasant. 

Place on the Whiskey Shelf

Mid Shelf

Brown Forman, you’ve done it again…but let me get to that thought later. First off – Jack Daniel’s Sinatra Select is actually fairly fragrant and flavorful for sipping neat, but also truly inoffensive and “soft” to the senses. Dare I say that Sinatra Select is the embodiment of a “smooth” whiskey, so Jack Daniel’s got that right. It’s an upgraded Gentleman Jack, and tastes a lot like Evan Williams Bottled in Bond because of the grassy nuttiness, but with less richness and depth, and less bite. Of all things, even at 90 proof I like how round and full the mouthfeel is, although the flavors unfortunately don’t quite match that.


Now let me continue to the bread portion of the open face compliment sandwich, where the bread is everything I don’t like. I was cautiously optimistic that this wouldn’t be the case, but Jack Daniel’s Sinatra Select unfortunately isn’t anything special. Price and low proof aside, it doesn’t even compare favorably to the under $20 Evan Williams Bottled in Bond or 11+ year old Elijah Craig barrel picks for under $40 (for better or worse, my ratings do not consider price). Sinatra Select has the representative Tennessee Whiskey and Bourbon honey, vanilla, oak, cinnamon, and mint flavors that are good; but the problem is that there’s little that I consider interesting, unique, or even noteworthy about it apart from the mouthfeel. Done blind without marketing, celebrity affiliations, or price tags, this is just a decent bourbon.


Pulling off the veil and seeing everything…is this seriously a $100+ whiskey? Brown Forman has done it again: released yet another whiskey that is priced so wildly out of reality that it had to be a prank. This is at best a $40 whiskey, so you’re primarily paying for the “commemorative” nature of the bottle and the Sinatra name. If you want a better “deal” from Brown Forman, go buy Woodford Reserve Batch Proof for a cool $130-150. This is in the running for the most overrated and overpriced whiskey I’ve drank this year. Even if you have a strong affinity towards Frank Sinatra, just please stay away. Frank Sinatra may have been smooth, but he certainly wasn’t uninteresting. You can thank me later and send me the savings. 

Other Reviews

Copyright 2019 - The Whiskey Shelf

[email protected]